U.S. District Court in Texas Blocks Corporate Transparency Act, Which Could Be a Win for Self-Storage OperatorsU.S. District Court in Texas Blocks Corporate Transparency Act, Which Could Be a Win for Self-Storage Operators

The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas recently blocked nationwide enforcement of the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA), questioning its constitutionality. Effective as of Jan. 1, 2024, and intended to fight money laundering, terrorist financing and other illegal activity, the law currently impacts approximately 32.6 million small businesses nationwide, including many in the self-storage industry, according to sources.

The court’s injunction applies to the requirement for most business entities to submit an annual Beneficial Ownership Information (BOI) report to the U.S. Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN). Thanks to this ruling, owners won’t need to file this report by the end of the year as initially stipulated. If the ban holds, they also won’t have to file after a significant business change or within 90 days of forming a new business entity.

The court ruled the CTA goes too far, as rules for businesses are typically set by the individual states. The law upsets the balance of power between state and federal governments, it said. The court also noted that the law would be very expensive for businesses to follow, costing an estimated $22 billion this year, without strong protections to prevent misuse of the information, the source reported.

Related:California, Illinois Self-Storage Lien Laws Now in Effect

The plaintiffs, including small-business owners and the National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB), argued that the CTA infringes on the First and Fourth Amendments, given the extensive personal information required. This case could set a precedent for courts to scrutinize federal initiatives that intrude into areas historically managed by states. Incoming President Donald Trump could limit or halt the CTA administratively, instead of passing new laws, as part of his focus on business deregulation, according to one source.

FinCEN filed an appeal on Dec. 5. The appellate court’s response is pending.

While the CTA isn’t exclusive to the self-storage industry, it'll affect many facility operators, particularly smaller, independent ones. Inside Self-Storage, a provider of industry education resources, published an article about the CTA in March to explain what it means and how to ensure compliance.

The NFIB is a nonprofit organization that represents more than 150,000 small and independent businesses nationwide. It advocates for policies that support small-business owners, such as lower taxes, less regulation and fewer government restrictions.

Sources:
Forbes, Court Blocks Corporate Transparency Act — A Win For Federalism? Updated
SSA Magazine Weekly, December 16, 2024.

Related:The 3 Prickly Ds of Self-Storage Operation: Tenant Divorce, Death and Disappearance