Self-Storage Valuation: A Technique for Checking an Appraisal's Fairness

Charles Ray Wilson Comments
Print
Continued from page 2

EGIM as a Predictor of Cap Rates

There’s a relationship between EGI and cap rate, expressed by the following formula: 

(1 - Expense Ratio) / EGIM = Cap Rate

If you’re not sure what the cap rate should be, you can use a range of EGIMs from sales in your neighborhood to derive a range of cap rates and see if the appraiser’s selected cap is within a reasonable range. Assuming EGIMs range between 7.5 and 8.5, as in Bill’s market, the cap-rate range would be: 

  • (1 - .35) / 7.5 = 8.7%
  • (1 - .35) / 7.7 = 8.4%
  • (1 - .35) / 8.0 = 8.1%
  • (1 - .35) / 8.2 = 7.9%

This exercise indicates that if the EGIM is based on local sales, and the operating expense ratios were taken into account when calculating the EGIM range, the appropriate cap rate would range between 7.9 percent and 8.7 percent, all else being equal.

In Bill’s case, we concluded the appraiser was too conservative on the estimate of EGI. We also concluded the cap rate of 9.5 used in the appraisal was well outside the indicted range. 

Get a Ballpark Estimate

The use of an EGIM is no substitute for having a compete appraisal, but if performed properly and with good data, it can provide a ballpark estimate facility value based on something other than the owner’s bias. An EGIM also allows for a fairness check on the appraiser’s cap rate. It’s important to compare apples to apples, and ensure the multiplier is applied to an estimate of EGI that reflects the facility’s historical performance trend.

The EGIM technique is just another tool, not a substitute for conducting a full appraisal. However, it does provide a logical starting point for a discussion of value that’s not just opinion-based.

Charles Ray Wilson is the founder of Self Storage Data Services Inc., an independent research firm that maintains the nation’s largest database of self-storage operating statistics. He is an internationally recognized leader in providing independent research on the self-storage industry. For more information, visit www.ssdata.net.

Related Articles:

Self-Storage Analyst Releases Optimistic Industry Results

Problems and Opportunities Play Major Role in Self-Storage Investment Market

Five Steps to the Best Self-Storage Facility Appraisal

« Previous123Next »
Comments
comments powered by Disqus